Verb/noun/type
From eg
remote havoc 2 tamiya ta04 manual registry file location makaha oahu beach rentals mathematics multiplication nancy and michael lippman patrick arundell word blinkies restaurant empire free game nbc los angeles local news 100 ceramic hair straighteners sphynx 36 week pregnancy london accommodation piccadilly line wxyz channel 7 news detroit no taskbar amira casar roy scherer virginia charter 1606 sejur actor wallpapers license2 lindhurst nj alabama apartment homewood rental pearl jam yeild lyrics nicole lowery 1 century estate real plage nudiste photo steroid biotransformation 61hs10 kp resident evil 4 krauser images marine trolling battery prolite e431s s services for battered women autobarn mazda architecture graduate school rankings internet service anywhere what is armistice day resita rectus abdominal fascia 2005 crvena jabuka stephensons rocket game illumination scent victorian design era escort lausanne 45 female gymnast old year the bs motorola invalid battery adhesion assay protocol sex auction employee discount code 2003 microsoft pc pocket window x men wolverine cartoon rio brazilian steakhouse houston kitchen lowes.com melanoma signs symptoms jongerius fnv litchfield national park nt axis allies revised inn grand fork minnesota wildly delicious foods pokoemon live haitian internet radio from haiti w s tyler pennsylvania child support chart augustine cabin florida rental st westeminster kennel club equipment fitness home zuma previsioni tempo roma ligaments of the ankle joint rock a bye baby furniture jp morgen ontario science center jazz louis vitton biography 55 community pa mgb auto for sale endangered species photos tata indicom advertisement summitt hospital oakland ca knit poncho direction effexor rxlist wordperfect serial key portal toolkit download 800ss ducati the bonfire of the vanities by tom wolfe age of empires conquerors downloads mastodon tooth omb police supplies the love you want a guide for couple apartment for rent ontario intercept text messages one giant leap cd its late lyric street too resimli maps of the north pole attire golf womens 10 cav addiction drug maryland treatment wire hbo renewed jesuit college and university podcast rss feed generator birthday party invitation korn falling away from me emule test connection waterproof paint thestreet.com passion of the christ hank hightower pic bite no orly affordable supplements quilting store long tongue celiac disease verwertungsgesellschaft wort st joseph seminary louisiana jackson pollack inusitate betting odds alaska vacation king county washington sidewalk permit internet jeff millions paul shortcut voodun each other people shitting animals penis 411 reverse lookup scrapbooking sites refinance refinancing refinancing goldmedalmortgage.com cellular emerald downs adtran our lady of guadalupe school coach purse moms fuking son modeling portfolio color healing new york natural gas supplier installation lift surrey hydraulic error nuker crack code michelfelder candidate united kingdom health insurance best home based business opportunities inuyasha jakotsu rare stamps just stay here and drink lyrics roberts brothers properties llc love waits livin on a prayer philmore victorian night gowns studebaker holiday art.com gothic vampire speed dating ottawa accords stsadm panorama szczecin annual beach florida miami property rental hand left snowmobile throttle stella mcartney addidas executive recruiter port 2257 dizzy gillespie oscar peterson akc ratchet supercharged 69 corvette a man called peter book flooring 3d house design software texas department of public safety free practice driving test soap leg cramps wadler kaplan music wang chung everybody have fun julia schultz movies new world vulture wahoo schools tour winter yellowstone arkansas department human resource polyethylene tarps electric rc airplanes free young lolita galleries easter symbols for children chair lift ramp wheel noseybonk peyman milanfar reel utility wire brock high voltage cable protection scooby 21 day in sql teach yourself leisure activity for the elderly usns mercy t ah 19 animal games dvd birmingham noah wyle lamarckian theory of evolution replica swords uk ronee blakely air campbell compressor hausfeld maxus neopet.com practicing hinduism reba mcintire used palletizers taxi bosch aquastar tankless water heater asp web page template organ donation used audi uk the urn tomb at petra luxury car rental gi joe california oceanside rental vacation ripley derbyshire hotels 1967 act civil right alison arngrim love of boy swimmers latest java update download eva airlines otto nelly and tim mcgraw over and over again lyric interstitial cystitis food hairy pussy young seeve epcot center orlando fl student credit cards with no apr everest communications kc sport clips kathy smith sciencetology trade show display equipment stadium seats wilmer valderama height no cost people locator tibia aid around neck ring wear free animated avatars edu espn.go.com linkdomain site drake university 2006 day mayberry effects of nuclear weapons testing amc studio 30 olathe ks university teaching jobs canada tara dakides snowboard lucky star pretear just 4 kid campingworld.com win weider weight lifting equipment nw magazine australia teacup yorkshire terrier for adoption kawasaki motorcycle racing accessories wrangler concept online mba programs mobiliario para hoteles lemon plant tree website graphics free rod parsley guys underwear shirtless top ten hentai movies what the bleep 9700 pro drivers roxy jezel free lau tak wah contrators canada infinity nissan allison kraus schools to be a fashion buyer warren county missouri paddlewheel for boat novelty buttons nelson mandela biography women in afghanistan ichat away message itunes mini storage rental contract jasmine trias abc soaps in depth talk back propertybag in vb post job openings mussels my american heart mhhe.com santrock arbor day manga pics occupational health and safety professional audio speakers nea zealand immigration tiger woods dad died chloroform scene of girl in video les mecs comique latin queens gang vavle steam store open 24 hours aluminum atv ramp ektelon racketball rackets apartment athens greece sale school girls in tights arowana tank mates kadamba steelers football mein herr cabaret lyrics show tickets boost free mobile ring tone eltcaaltroca m.i.a. clep hybrid security door clairvoyance calendar maker medallions wildlife photos popcapgames audio tape methotrexate fedora hats pocket rocket vibrator nicole ricca public flash web site marketing strategies royalty free ideas latin beauties florida campgrounds business hosting public thongs hydraulic pumps les claypool shinedown 45 teagames juno email injuries clothes off al capone enema nurse motorcycle gloves discount patio furniture mrs vette perb sardinia 60s montreal hotels silverado extended cab sub box come as you are nirvana me data acquisition owls ferrari cars reverse osmosis water filter dvd x copy campground for sale old navy map of alberta ocala homes for sale roy clark kauai condo fresh produce fashion jewelry cluster headaches anthropologie microsoft photo editor asvab vegas homes www.televisionwithoutpity.com renaissance art whitesnake irish folk music two girls one guy saucony races search engine marketing game house spy gadgets sprinkler pillar human skeleton debate baseballs no tan lines south park characters jennifer ellison iron chef the tick www.petsmart.com dont lie water polo champion homes michelle behennah farm supplies rock the boat claw foot tubs hardy boyz information security diet plans video equipment weight control hypnosis world of warcraft salma dog stuff american indian cat food pool tables for sale data conversion services house foreclosure innova dog food tila dss files paintball stores mathematics laptop parts myflorida.com financial advisors bed and breakfast prom hair wind power saw casino black jack uhaul exchange rate calculator dunst black crowes parking driving distance lottery software ceiling tiles sea monkey online web site design builder sedu hair straighteners french translation toy dolls seti(at)home california strippers outlandish dragonfly tattoo wedding vows screen savers roush police dogs real player free download aoi brooklyn bridge rory gallagher ya plastic injection molding maria shriver download emule welders pmoy leadership management training real estate in idaho laptop repair atb mp3 taxonomy message boards motor scooter diabetic shoes brotha lynch problem solving stagga lee ivy tech hayley finch protools consumer reports on roomba beauties michael jackson beat it hands down white house black market milkshake sggirls rolling thunder golf putters kate chopin manhattan project gauges super man hoovers the heart combination lock canton repository japan girls cool pics lilac desperado eagles memphis relocation senior life settlement peter kitchen counter tops plastic rod corporate governance kids in the way neo pets.com escort services carmen garcia the girls next door grandma jack and the beanstalk interrati john stamos campbell hausfeld garden storage sheds joss stone kim delaney rich mullins gas pump free real voice ringtones for sprint pcs lil flip ringtones free nokia 6820 ringtones how to get metro pcs ringtone for free nextel i850 ringtone maker 2270 nokia ringtone send sms ringback ringtone verizon wireless the apprentice theme ringtone free nextel ringtone web site the girl next door ringtone fre ringtone carey life mariah ringtone time free ringtone voice x ringtones nokia 6100 ringtone download fast ringtone v120c samsung e105 ringtone format free get i730 nextel ringtone wav 1150 free lg ringtone fire fighter ringtone cabin crew star to fall ringtone nokia 6610 ringtones format e530 ringtone samsung fraggle rock mp3 ringtone 700w ringtone treo free mcgraw ringtone tim ringtone toadies how we do game ringtone interpol ringtones free 8181ringtones free reggaeton ringtone 6600 nokia ringtone ringtones australia whole lotta love truetone samsung sch a850 ringtones free arabic polyphonic ringtone don t forget about us ringtone office ringtone song theme against me ringtones kyocera phantom polyphonic ringtones australian polyphonic ringtones doctorringtones cell phone ringtone sending ringtone lg vx zelda ringtones free boost music ringtone samsung t500 ringtones free frog ringtones 87140 ringtones download download free free.com ringtone ringtone ringtone ringtone v265 ringtones download download ringtones free bollywood 2 free myc polyphonic ringtone sagem jam kiss last pearl ringtone real tones ringtone download ringtone free tstt i830 nextel ringtones nokia6610 ringtones iowa fight song ringtones phone ringtones free 700 palm ringtone treo hedwigs theme ringtone 2.3.16 converter mobile ringtone free lg3200 ringtones john legend ringtone 3100 nokia ringtone ringtones lg vx norma jean ringtones o2 x2 free ringtones radiohead ringtones tamilsongs ringtones chariots of fire ringtone nirvana ringtone candy shop ringtone media ringtone studio free mobile ringtone user virgin monophonic cell phone ringtone cand shop ringtone 2 hearts kingdom ringtone ringtone on to phone from computer 7210 nokia polyphonic ringtone valkyries ringtone cena john ringtone free ring ringtone ringtone ringtonesdownloadsfree.com tone free oc ringtones ringtones for an audiovox phone lg8 ringtone free telugu ringtones for nokia ring tones wireless ringtones compatible with att phones casting crowns ringtones free tamil polyphonic ringtones 120c motorola ringtone media plazza ringtones to make nextel ringtones free might mobile pcs phone ringtone saver screen sprint anime polyphonic ringtones jutebox ringtones ringing phone ringtone virgin mobile kyocera free ringtones tony sopranos ringtone notre dame fight song ringtone dysphagia rate me nude staples office california tourism hair loss remedies build outdoor fireplace nun hentai snow plow updo casenet rani mukherjee silk flower hussyfan enkei wheels free online slots friendfinder windchimes brazil soccer lorac orbit sprinklers dirty aly stomach ache angel pictures hot girls pics honda goldwing jason branch kingda ka yamaha atv parts bb gunns butthole surfers dickie virgin free christian chat room bleeding heart plant sex in kitchen alexboys snowflakes lynne coupon code watch tv biome honda canada urban design nike dunk adult literature sex porn firestone tires postpartum depression ta8403 corsica konica minolta discount blinds stadium chairs big ass women picnic table music sites links best bank of america online banking dean phoenix ronaldo samsung dlp legion of doom conan the barbarian wood burning fireplace lesbian porn video body scrub beck anxiety inventory lesbians dildo sexy parties online pregnancy test mr chew asian beaver naked granny escorts uk helicopters for sale preteen links lesbian action online quizzes prison sex free pussy pics slumber parties women of home depot colorado clothing padme naked game winners bet on sports d12 mp3 frankie gotti selma barbosa barbie dolls viractin j r music world adult free porn quilting foot free best man speeches stacys mom banana republic outlet store currency rate fingernails knee braces buy used medical equipment webmail free orgasm metformin flexeril anime pussy greyhound bus line information on metformin carolina herrera for men employee background check cialis online generic job application form masks fioricet cod buy celexa download online games printable cigarette coupon shaw carpets cytomel nursing schools in michigan myspace slideshow american leather furniture video gay pocket knife pussy cum buy clomid orange beach student insurance full movies search and destroy hawaii mls gaeta italy pill identifier amsouth bank lingerie free math worksheets metal spiral staircase massage chair wet pussy lipitor coffee franchises engagement rings armstrong flooring namenda sex amatuer shower curtain used hotel furniture asiana airline how to lay shingles erika eleniak ephedra danger reliant stadium audiovox ringtones tauk tours carolina herrera oxaprozin housesforsale sofa express mortgage calculator uk curtains tommy hilfiger handbag meatloaf recipes kitchen design gallery alfa romeo car baby bedding black bbw porn gaskets reserve ps3 fireplace mantle designs buy phendimetrazine people search zaba trailer hitch fallen shoes suzuki boulevard www webmail bellsouth net vancouver school board continuing education tissot whey kimbo sex pictures beagle miami vice public relations massari soul on fire lyrics national weather service in tulsa interest rates realplayer accident reconstruction free napster auto loan boost free mobile ring tone college girl download free porn losartan free reverse phone lookup holiday tours public schools tennessee state university website cigarette sale aircanada drug chanel purse what do i need to copy vhs to dvd air force fire protection american day great x box rainbow six 3 cheat code aborigines government internet explorer pictures blurry in situ definition science alabama county population astronomy ohio state active in usa volcano i lyric said said she wow yes php info test i dream of you every night lost in space episode adventure mario nes pregnant woman photos psychology masters degree pneumonia definition limousines in san diego us president day masonry ties mazda used wheels live chat cams amsterdam metro maps joyce meyers home acid stained flooring alphabet download font graffiti jim montague raw nikon d70 lil jon mp3 pick up big american bar association tax los simpsons fotos journal of heat transfer mx 900 review eh eso michigan properties rental vacation images of alyssa spa manicures red sea terrorism www eplan on your mark get set smoke a cigarette stainless steel braided art business craft start supply seagate sata hard drives the melodrama academic subject directory experience synonym manager poker tournament assign contracts media player will not play wmv jersey city police stations info.net university of nebraska football ticket air discount hotel las package vegas legal statute of limitations technical support web sites system selector whistling lyrics art gallery johnson city virginia landscape palm picture tree 64 bit world phone from morocco audio library software achievement levels eucation required for a crime scene investigator ass big black fuck irs tax jim powers dont tell mommy too many meetings en language officer said security taipei towers microsoft access calendar control windows xp usb keyboard iowa asset protection electrical workbenches online sports trivia praying christians which broadband portugal ultras renew your drivers license online the o.c. music episode teacher education accreditation council ac power cord color code japanese woodworking american top model 3 texas travel destinations scottsdale arizona golf properties russian beauty eyewitness new news york properties for rent in spain online lpn training new video release dates inter mediates methods of performance appraisals american institute of business iowa nicaragua missions kia rating novartis international panic attack breathing exercises top 10 automobile manufacturers kid snow nfl games tickets official language of egypt 400 best camcorder under lotus noir 5 percent club entrees made easy parker yamaha small garage designs robin petersen sonts dot com reference encyclopedias test cricket south africa oxygen phase diagram whos on my page my space tracker adobe cs photo shop software institute software training new best seller america discount tires thesaurus web service address return label jazz music smooth station anglo american mining company reinstall ie6 windows 2000 javascript confirm title ixy digital paul fosse suck him dry london kings college jimi henrix lyrics rise against lyrics should smoking be allowed in public place auto becker radio small oil leak springfield virginia hilton ex smith wife will van morrison photo 20 years toshiba hdtv 30 in kine algebric formula ablation plasma 1997 jeep part sale wisconsin make money at home windows xp dual core microsoft office professional 2003 full income maintenance worker who wrote the gospel of mark political science distance learning senescent superbowl half time show 2005 nature mp3s little girl bathing suit picture restoration software 250 air conditioning home unit up american association of architect american expresss uk inspiring jewish stories tickets west end shows e world publishing texas buyer agent liquid vitamin for kid sereno wife that want to fuck stainless steel screw cap swatch .com music for love in any language quebec civil laws indian restaurant grand junction colorado south park rain forest pioneer xm to go add house link industrial engineering chemistry research news papers in south carolina lebanon city pa resume accounts payable engine marketing search travel are they jack black school of rock pictures notion of liberty pfizer and pharmaceutical sales shes a one in a million girl ingenieria economica uk recruitment consultants wyeth canada inc xslt 2.0 international convenant on spor arabalar use you love tonight pacific trading card picture pomegranates zone alarm manual uninstall wedding in az underaged girls s fone website exercise induced pulmonary pci express video cards nvidia ice hockey equipment shops trapezoid rule example ricacchirolt relvarrice A REST protocol emerges from use in a verb/noun/type sequence:
- REST requires agreeing on the verb list quite early, as all nouns will be required to support these verbs.
- e.g. if pages change only via wiki protocol this involves defining user editable web pages and redefining such functions as delete into verb:redirect.
- Mechanical command verbs become distinct from social control verb
- As nouns emerge out of control of the protocol author, e.g. from the GFDL corpus, applicability of verbs will be tested and refinements made to the protocol.
- Standards, e.g. GFDL corpus namespace, including accredited standards, will intersect with both the noun and verb list, requiring refactoring
- Most interaction remains manual, but may include human command verbs (that imply roles, deference and usually command hierarchy, e.g. based on infrastructure owners trust) as some of the nouns describe elements of more reflective processes.
- A defining vocabulary specifies construction of complex nouns from the simplest ones.
- A taxonomy specifies relationships between nouns relative to each process, e.g. steps required to join a web service may require login or suggest you use real name.
- Associating verbs to nouns implies types.
- Simply observing what verbs are being applied to what nouns creates a weak ontology. This can often be done statistically with web server statistics. HTTP errors can be a rich source of information on what verbs were expected to work with what nouns and should always recover cleanly - similar to the missing method redirect in Smalltalk. This is one justification for replacing delete with verb:redirect.
- Functions and protocols already automated should be integrated into a firm ontology suitable for routine use and reports, but not for mission-critical functions necessarily
- Full quality control discipline involves a reflexive process in which every aspect of a type definition and refinement process is subject to the same investigation/refinement.
Contents |
[edit] precedents: minimizing the effort of associating verbs, nouns and types
Developers must uderstand the precedents that apply to any given application domain. REST tries to keep nouns, verbs and types (which associate many verbs or operators with each noun) in separate development silos, in part because the precedents are so different. A common view is that MIME types exist independently of nouns and verbs, but all such types result from previous efforts to identify nouns, e.g. a document, and associated verbs, e.g. print.
Major sources of precedent include HTTP and GIS (most important), DAML+OIL, AJAX.
[edit] = distinguishing human command from machine command
A particularly thorny problem is to keep ontological distinctions made by authority out of definitions so that no particular deference is required. Ideally users must agree only on operational distinctions. Each role implies its own set of verbs defined by a job description or other contract.
Diligent ontologists will find all control verbs, role-implied types, and associated human commands, e.g. issued by user boss to user, conditions laid by host to operator, threats from sysop to trolls. Differentiating command, control and human command.
[edit] wiki protocol
Craig Hubley's wiki protocol proposal uses verbs: GET, PUT and POST (includes watch and patch), REDIRECT (includes delete), LOCK (includes publish). No means to verb:authenticate is required, as it can be considered an atomic combination of REDIRECT/LOCK/PUT (assuming one attempts to do something and then must login or otherwise authenticate - see verb:try for more on this.
He says "LOCK and PUBLISH relate much like PUT and POST and could be more differentiated - a published version is locked, but to lock anything is to say it's better in this form than alternatives trolls are proposing, so you could be assumed to be publishing it or something about it (like warnings). DELETE only serves to create HTTP error 404 so it is actually a form of REDIRECT (to an error page, but in wiki best practice to edit this page and in web best practice to find pages that might have been intended)." From a post on humanitarian-ict.
[edit] mobility
In the long term mobile applications used to make real decisions are going to need more verbs than HTTP or wiki and will require much more integration with where/when/who information. Hubley suggests using "ACT" as "a separate verb to report actions taken based on the instructions on a page, with LINK transit as an act. A really good implementation would defer/refer/infer as three different types of links." Perhaps.
A closely related issue is that worn devices radically simplify verbs involved in initiating and ending transactions, and the verb:lock may apply to streams such as the "mute" which makes other parties to conversations listeners only.
